The School Principal – Dr. Crowder’s Process for Examining the Strength of a School’s ELA Instructional Program

From time-to-time, principals with grade-level staff need to examine the strength of their instructional programs embedded within a school’s curriculum. Instructional units should be a delivery system to deliver teaching/learning/assessment. To do so, important criteria must be followed with an examination for evidence. Criteria for analysis are stated below:

Content Analysis

_What text(s) will be used in the unit activities?

_Is there evidence that the texts were evaluated for complexity?

_What evidence can be noted for the texts exhibiting exceptional craft and thought and/or

providing useful information? What are the central ideas of the texts?

_What is the intended learning for each activity within the unit?

_Which standard(s) are targeted for the unit activities?

_Does the unit and related activities plan for a majority of the time to be spent reading, writing or

speaking about the texts?

Student Performance Analysis

_How are questions, activities, and tasks designed and sequenced to guide students to the central

ideas and development of the texts to build knowledge?

_How are students expected to use evidence from the texts to demonstrate understanding and

support their ideas (e.g., Think, Pair, Share; journal; small group discussion, act it out, etc.)?

Language Analysis

_Which vocabulary words, phrases, and sentences demand time and attention because they are:

  • critical to comprehension, or
  • valuable words for students to know,
  • related to the central ideas of the text?

_How are they addressed in unit activities?

_If present, what is the culminating task for the unit? How will students demonstrate

understanding of the structure, concepts, ideas, or details of the texts?

_How are language and foundational skill practice addressed (for grades K-5, if applicable) in

the activities?

Instructional Method Practice Analysis

_What scaffolds are planned so that all students will persevere through difficult tasks?

_What supports are planned for students who read below grade level?

_What extensions are planned for students who read above grade level?

_What consideration and opportunities for student progress toward independent reading of these

texts are built into the activities?

Program Systemic Analysis

_Are there indications that these texts are part of a sequence designed to build knowledge?

_Is there evidence of how this unit and related activities fit within longer-term content goals?

_Is there evidence of support for increasing independence in reading, writing, or speaking?

Those interested in learning more about EdVistas’ ways to harness technology to gain early access to new student performance may do so by contacting Pete Cooper at 518-925-6021 or pcooper@edvistas.com.

Dr. Bruce H. Crowder is a senior researcher for Educational Vistas, Inc. His work is primarily focused on creating pathways for deeper learning for all students through student performance and a dynamic curriculum replete with strategic teaching. Dr. Crowder may be reached at bcrowder@edvistas.com